Originally Posted by Chasin Cars:
Long time lurker, first time poster. I've read this thread a couple of times and finally decided to post on it.
First, let me say that I'm a fan of sprint and midget racing, but I'm also a fan of IRL racing. We can all complain that we want 1996 back, but that isn't going to happen. What many of you fail to realize is that the business model simply wasn't working back then.
Tony G gave it a good try, but then did what he had to do to keep the doors open. If 1996 was so great, why were the stands so empty? Sure, we all supported it, but majority of America sports fans didn't come out and support Boat, Yeley, Stewart, etc. while in the IRL. I would argue that a larger percentage of today's general "motorsports" fans care much more about Tony Kanaan than they do Billy Boat.
What we need is a mix. That's what's made Indy so spectactular for nearly 100 years. Oval trackers vs. international superstars in the same race. Back then it was Foyt vs. Andretti. Today we need Hines vs. Kanaan. It should be about the best in the WORLD. Indianapolis 500 is an international event and should always be an international event. My argument has always been that no one ever had a problem rooting for or against Luyendyk, Mansell, Fittipaldi, etc., but now you suddenly have a problem with today's foreign drivers? What gives?
Just my opinion folks. Keep on racin!
Chasin Cars
Your opinion, like everyone's is valid. However I disagree with your opinion. I too thought that Tony G gave it a good try, but since he has come out since then and admitted that he always wanted a series like CART, that kind of throws that good effort argument out the window.
As far as a majority of America (sic) sports fans not supporting the early IRL, I'll only agree that not enough of them did. But as big as nascar is, a majority of sports fans don't support it either. All racing and all sports are niches, some much bigger than others, but still niches. The big problem comes when a series or a sport tries to be bigger than it's niche will support. Table Tennis at a top level is very difficult, yet that sport has a small following, so you won't find many if any pro table tennis players. I would say that a large percentage of today's motorsports fans don't know who Billy Boat or Tony Kannan are.
No one had a problem with foreign drivers in the past? I don't know about that, but I didn't. However one BIG difference is almost all of those foreign drivers in the past including the ones you mentioned were known quantities. They had records, winning records. Some were world champions when they came to Indycars. Imagine that, F1 a feeder series for Indycars. The problem came when foreign drivers without winning resume's showed up and actually took the place of winning Indycar drivers who were still in or near their prime. So that's what gives.
And like you, that is just my opinion.