Originally Posted by Frank Reiner:
A read-thru of the above noted rules for this venture shows us:
1) That the body of the rules have been taken (almost) verbatim from other existing rules.
2) That the IRP rules writers seem not to have consulted with any sources who have already implemented engine preparation specifications and rules for "stock" based engines. As currently stated the "rules" are so minimalist that any participant, whether racer or official, can interpret those rules however it suits them.
With a bit of luck, the good folks at IRP will step back, and take the time to ask questions of, and listen to the advice from, sources such as MARA/BMARA who are running very successful "stock" based engines.
Disclaimer: I enjoy watching the races and I think it's great that the series had the bump in car counts and all that; but, this appears to be an intended different direction than the BMARA rules (I'd have to think maybe by choice, but I could be wrong). If this series wants to keep the claim part of it - there is no way you could have a $15,000 claim rule with the BMARA platform (some used engines cost that much; yes you can buy others for less; but those are not consistently running in the top 4). And, this series has a basis on the Ford Focus engine; which, I believe were around 200hp. Those would be outclassed by the BMARA engines (not saying anything bad about it, just reality). So ya, I'd think - with these rules - you could squeak a lot more HP/torque out of the ECO choice. I gather it is an attempt to bring out the Focus and ECOs that have been mothballed ("already" - Focus stuff could be like 20 years old by now though); than "just" using a stock block, head, crank at 2.4L (which, yes, has put on some great racing and can be just as fast or faster than National cars; and, although more than $15,000 in many cases, it certainly is cheaper than a National engine).
PS - again, this is not a dig, but there were no ECOTECHS consistently running in the top 4 in BMARA the last couple years. It is Hondas and Fords (not Focus Fords; but Rick Kipley's). And, of course, chassis set up and driving is just as, and in some cases, more important than HP/Torque.