Sullivan's at Keystone at the Crossing gives St. Elmo's a big run for its money. A little pricey like St. Elmo's, but the filet is among the best you'll ever eat. It has a nice swanky-type New York City vibe and there is usually plenty of eye candy! Famous types like Bob and Tom, some Colts and Larry Bird can be seen there on occasion.

I can't believe you guys put Ted's and Rock Bottom in the same conversation with these other steakhouses! Those places are definitely good, but not in the same class as an Elmo's, etc.