I'm sure its a matter of personal preference. I got into dirt track racing in Virginia, early 1960s, "Coupes".... jalopies, sportsmen, modified. We moved back up North in 1966, I went to 2 races on pavement, lost all interest.
Fast forward 40 years, a friend gave me a Circle Track magazine, it mentioned sprint cars in Pa. I was going there the next day, found a race (on dirt!) was hooked again, been going the last 7 years
I don't think there's any right or wrong to it, not trying to convince anyone, dirt just seems more exciting to me....