I'm not arguing he would be my number 1 choice but what about Jeff Gordon. Especially in his prime he could race anything. He has been out of open wheel cars probably too long now though.

I might have taken Tony Sewart before he broke his leg. It's been all down hill since for him.

I will go with Rico. He seems to win in whatever you put him in. He also puts on one heck of a show. Even in winged racing when not many others can make lines work.